纠错
置顶

Jomon Pottery

纠错

What is the purpose of paragraph 5 in relation to the passage as a whole?

Click on an oval to select your answer. To choose a different answer,

click one different oval.

  • A
    To provide a further reason that supports the theory for the invention of pottery discussed in paragraph 2
  • B
    To provide an explanation for the invention of pottery that avoids the problems with the explanation discussed in preceding paragraphs
  • C
    To propose a social explanation for the northern movement of the Jomon people described in paragraph
  • D
    To contradict the assumptions made in paragraph 4 about the radiocarbon dating of pottery
显示答案
正确答案: B

我的笔记 编辑笔记

  • 原文
  • 译文
  • The oldest known pottery in the world comes from Japan, and is known as Jomon, which means "cord marks", after its typical decorations made by impressing cords into the wet clay. The earliest Jomon pottery is dated to around 14,000 B.C., considerably earlier than any pottery produced in Europe and western Asia, the earliest of which dates to approximately 8,000 B.C.



    Why should the Jomon people have been so inventive? Why were they making pottery so much earlier than anywhere else in the world? Only pottery from China comes remotely close to it in date, and there it is explained by the requirements of rice cultivation. Melvin Aikens, an authority on the Jomon period, believes that Japanese pottery was invented to cook and store the produce of the thick broad-leaved woodlands that had already covered Kyushu, Japan's southernmost main island, by 13,000 B.C. The relationship is evident, he argues, from the simultaneous spread of broad-leaved woodlands and pottery into the northern islands of Japan, both appearing on the northernmost island of Hokkaido at around 7,000 B.C.



    There are,however, two problems with this idea. First, there is no necessity for hunter-gatherers to have pottery when living in wooded environments-the inhabitants of other villages of this era, such as Ain Mallaha in western Asia at 12,500 B.C. and Star Carr in northern Europe at 9, 500 B.C., flourished by relying entirely on vessels made from bark, skins, wood, and stone. Pottery no doubt made life easier for those who did the cooking in the woodlands of Kyushu, and we know from food residues that pottery vessels had indeed been used to make vegetable, meat, and fish stews. But people could have easily survived without such vessels.



    A second problem for Aikens'theory arose in 1999 when a new sample of pottery was found in northern Honshu(Japan's largest island). Radiocarbon dates on the residues stuck to the interior of the pot dated to 14, 500 B.C., pushing back the origin of pottery by at least another thousand years. At this date Honshu would have had no more than a sparse covering of pine trees. And so the theory that Japanese pottery was invented to store and cook the produce of broad-leaved woodlands cannot be correct.



    An archaeologist, Brian Hayden, has proposed an alternative explanation. It provides another example of his belief in social competition as the driving force of social change that he applied in explaining the origin of squash cultivation in Mexico. Hayden suggests that ceramic vessels have a number of important qualities that make them prestigious objects to own and ideal containers for serving food to guests. At the outset, the potter's art would have been difficult to master; clay had to be carefully selected, tempers (materials added to clay to reduce its plasticity)prepared, and construction and firing techniques explored, practiced, and refined. Neighbors and other visitors would have been struck with the amount of labor and skill required to produce a pottery vessel. The display of novel forms with fancy decoration would have impressed them even more. Most striking of all might have been the dramatic smashing of vessels during feasts as an ostentatious display of wealth.



    Theatrical smashing of pots may have occurred in the later Jomon period, as immense piles of broken pottery have been found. And as they come in astonishingly elaborate forms, there can be no doubt that many later Jomon vessels were primarily for display. They have spectacular rims modeled as licking flames or serpents winding around the vessel. Sometimes the decoration is so top-heavy that the pots can hardly stand alone. Lacquered (glossy) objects must have been very striking. But we must be cautious about applying such interpretations to the earliest and rather dull specimens of pottery. We currently know too little about the very earliest pottery makers of Japan to decide whether they had been more concerned with impressing their visitors or devising a means to cook vegetable stew. We do know, however, that by 9, 500B.C. many were living sedentary lives in permanent settlements. Although pottery had already been invented, the sedentary lifestyle must have been crucial in enabling ceramic technology to flourish.


  • 暂无译文

  • 官方解析
  • 网友贡献解析
  • 标签
    0 感谢 不懂
    解析

    【题型】修辞目的题

    【解析】题干问的是第五段在全文中的目的。先看段落首句,Hayden提出了另一个解释。关于Jomon人为什么发明陶器,第二段先提出了Aikens的解释,然后第三四段提出了Aikens理论存在的两个问题,接着在第五段提出了另一种不同的解释。选项B的意思是,针对陶器的发明,提供了一个解释,该解释避开了前文解释中存在的问题,符合文章结构。

    选项A的意思是,提供了另外一个原因,支持第二段的理论,可是第五段是提出了不同于第二段的解释。

    选项C的意思是,为 Jomon人向北迁徙提供了社会解释,解释的对象完全错了。

    选项D的意思是,推翻了第四段里关于陶器年份的假设,可是第五段完全没有提及年份。

题目讨论

如果对题目有疑问,欢迎来提出你的问题,热心的小伙伴会帮你解答。

最新提问