纠错

阅读材料

In the nineteenth century North American bison populations were reduced to near extinction for a variety of reasons, all of which are human-related and a result of settler activity in the region. bison population has undergone wide fluctuations in size throughout history; however, human activity, including using bison as a food source, introduction of animal species that competed for habitat, and hunting, all dramatically reduced herd populations.

Early North American settlers and Native American Indians relied on bison as a food source. nomadic hunters would follow herd movements across the plains and to the Rocky Mountains where bison grazing trails had been established. it is estimated that 20 to 30 million bison once dominated the North American landscape and it was in part this gigantic population that led many people to believe that bison was an inexhaustible and limitless supply of food. as the settlers moved west, over-consumption of the bison reduced bison populations to less than 2,000 before the turn of the nineteenth century.

During the American Civil War period, humans introduced many other grazing species that directly competed with bison for habitat and food resources. these species included cattle and horses which forced bison into smaller and smaller pockets of habitat. this had the result of bison directly competing with each other for food. under these circumstances, it is no wonder bison populations were quickly decimated.

Technological developments in the accuracy and range of rifles also had a considerable impact on bison herd populations. the new rifles allowed for increased accuracy from increased distances so that the slaughter of bison became easier and easier. the increased mortality of these new rifles, coupled with the fact that many people took up bison hunting for sport, pushed bison to the brink of complete annihilation.

听力材料 精听本文>>>

查看听力原文 关闭听力原文
Historical records indicate almost complete decimation of North American bison populations which only in recent years have been restored to sustainable numbers. The reading passage is, however, too quick to place the blame of bison endangerment on human activity. Let me give you a few examples of why the reading passage is incorrect.

Firstly, if bison population endangerment was directly related to human consumption, then we would expect to see that bison population numbers reduced in tandem with the westward movement of early North American settlers. This is not the case however as historical records indicate no reduction of herd population from east to west. Instead, records indicate a geographic reduction in herd numbers starting in the west.

Secondly, bison are the largest, toughest, and possibly most aggressive, North American grazing species. The assertion in the reading passage that cattle and horses forced bison out of their natural grassland grazing habitats is a bit farfetched. Bison are not easily intimidated animals and would have no problem competing with cows and horses, largely domestic and docile creatures, for food. Furthermore, bison habits included cold and mountainous regions, areas that cows and horses would find quite unsuitable for living and grazing.

Lastly, placing the blame on rifle improvements is wholly erroneous. Newly improved rifles had the same mortality rate as the traditional bow and arrow hunting methods and older rifles. Looking at similar large game animals in other areas of the world, we do not see evidence to support gun technology advancements as a reason for population decline. If this were the case, we would expect to see drastic reductions of other large, wild beasts following the introduction of new rifle technology.
问题

Summarize the points made in the lecture you just heard, explaining how they cast doubt on the specific theories discussed in the reading passage.

练习本题
查看笔记

精华内容

  • 答题思路
  • 高分作文
  • 范文
  • 题目讨论
  • 名师思路
  • The reading material explains that North American bison populations were reduced to near-extinction due to human-related factors such as overconsumption, introduction of competing grazing species, and hunting. However, the listening material casts doubt on this theory by providing evidence that suggests otherwise.

     

    Firstly, the reading material points out that the westward movement of early North American settlers who relied on bison as a food source may be the primary cause of the reduction in bison populations. In contrast, the professor asserts that historical records show a geographic reduction in bison herd numbers starting in the west, rather than a decrease in bison populations from east to west.

     

    Furthermore, the reading material suggests that cattle and horses were introduced and forced bison out of their natural habitats. However, the lecturer challenges this theory by pointing out that bison are tough and aggressive animals that can compete with other grazing species for food. Additionally, bison are adapted to survive in cold and mountainous regions that cows and horses may find unsuitable for living and grazing.

     

    Lastly, the reading material mentions that advancements in rifle technology had a considerable impact on bison populations. However, the listening material disputes this theory by stating that similar large game animals in other parts of the world did not experience population declines following the introduction of new gun technology. This implies that rifle improvements may not have been the sole or primary cause of the reduction in bison populations.

     

  • 会员福利内容准备中,丰富答题思路即将上线

最新提问